A student writes:
Dear Dr. V.,
I have a question that stemmed from our culture test. One of the items in the
study guide stated that culturally Deaf couples tend to hope for a Deaf baby.
Why is that? It was an interesting fact to learn, and I would love to know the
reasoning behind it.
Thanks,
- [Student's name removed to protect his/her privacy]
=====================================================
Dear ___________,
Many Deaf couples who want to become parents wish for their child to be Deaf.
In addition to cultural reasons this desire is based on a conscious or
subconscious realization that a Deaf child will tend to grow up being part of
the world of the Deaf parent whereas a Hearing child will tend to grow up being
mainly involved in the Hearing world. If as a Deaf parent, my child is born Deaf
that means he/she has a higher probability of:
1. Attending a school for the Deaf - which will be staffed with people who sign
and to whom I will have full communicative access.
2. Having Deaf friends and playmates whom will sign and to whom I will have full
communicative access.
3. Dating someone who is Deaf and to whom I will have full communicative access.
4. Falling in love with and marrying someone who is Deaf (or at least a signer)
to whom I will have full communicative access.
5. Having Deaf babies to whom I will have full communicative access (and who
will love to come visit grandpa because grandpa is Deaf like them and can sign
with them).
6. Establishing a visually accessible Deaf household complete with visual
communication technology such as a "video phone," and a "door light" instead of
a "door bell."
7. Coming to visit me when I'm old and being able to sign with me when they do
come visit.
If a child is born "hearing" that means the opposite of all of the items above.
The child will attend a public (Hearing) school staffed by people who don't
sign. He/she will have Hearing playmates and friends who don't sign. He/she will
date and marry a person who doesn't sign and with whom I can't communicate.
His/her children will likely not be good signers due to growing up "hearing."
All of which will reduce the Deaf parents' ability to access and be involved in
their child's world.
That is why Deaf couples hope for a Deaf baby. Imagine if there was a chance
that you gave birth to a baby who would automatically grow up to speak Chinese
and not English? The older your child gets the less English they know and use
and the more they switch to Chinese until they don't speak English very well at
all and only hang out with Chinese speakers and go to a Chinese speaking school
where the teachers speak Chinese? They marry a Chinese speaking mate
and create grandbabies that end up speaking Chinese (who don't want to visit you
since you don't speak Chinese). They will tend to want to spend holidays
at the "other" parents' house since those parents speak the language of the
grandchildren. Your child would become less and less a part of your world
each day.
That is how it typically is for Deaf parents of Hearing babies.
- Dr. V
=====================================================
Notes:
Notes: